Comparative Methodological Critique - 3073 Words

Comparative Methodological Critique Introduction The aim of this paper is to compare two academic research papers, one informed by qualitative and another one by quantitative research designs with focus on the methodological factors. Both papers describe working lives and attitudes of gay and lesbian workers in the UK and USA, possible consequences of disclosure of sexual orientation on their working relations and organisational arrangements towards equality and diversity of working practice. These research projects add to the growing number of studies which shed light on the sensitive nature of homosexuality in the workplace and anti-discrimination policies and practices that organisations deploy to create a more inclusive working†¦show more content†¦Whereas the Regulations empowered LGB people to step in and â€Å"challenge discrimination and harassment† (Colgan et al., 2007:604), the key factor, as identified by the authors, â€Å"that prevented some respondents coming out at work †¦ the fear† (Colga n et al., 2007) remained the main obstacle to LGB workers to blowing the whistle and reporting an incident. These findings are supported and justified throughout the paper by respondents’ statements and results of previous studies. The research team also defined the relation between the impact of the employment equality (SO) regulations, considered as independent variable, and such dependent variables like job satisfaction, being out at work, experience of harassment and discrimination, this in fact gives an idea of the existing problem in organisational practices. In terms of structure, language and appropriateness of referencing to other material this paper proves highly informative. It suggests that further research needs to be done in order â€Å"to gain a more â€Å"representative† picture of working lives of LGB employees† (Colgan et al., 2007) as it only explored the â€Å"tip of the iceberg†, because the research project was able to examine only a fraction of the whole, and, unless an organisation adopts more effective and proactive leadership on equality and diversity, the legislation onShow MoreRelatedComparative Effectiveness And Quality Improvement Of Public Healthcare Systems Essay1113 Words   |  5 PagesGSPH5900 Comparative Effectiveness Quality Improvement of Public Healthcare Systems Fall 2016 Assignment I: Article Critique on â€Å"Comparative Performance of Private and Public Healthcare Systems in Low-and Middle-Income Countries: A Systematic Review† Essentially, every country’s health care providers are categorized into either public or private. This particular article enlists six categories of health care providers including multinational and national for-profit corporations; formal individualRead MoreEssay on Charge Nurse838 Words   |  4 Pagescompetences Charge nurse p 2. A qualitative study of charge nurse competencies This is a research critique of a qualitative study concerning the charge nurse role in medical-surgical and intensive care units. The purpose of this article is to identify the competencies needed of nurses serving in the charge nurse role, and to identify barriers and facilitatorsRead MoreRequest For Conversion Of An Advance Contract1683 Words   |  7 Pagesprovided a practical guide for employing this method in social science research. Now they do the same for additional causal case study methods, including small-n comparative and congruence methods as well as process tracing. Causal case study methods have attained a level of maturity where it is no longer necessary to define methodological foundations and principles merely by how they differ from quantitative, variance-based methods. What social scientists want to know is how causal case study methodsRead MoreThe Nature and Role of the Entrepreneur Essay2031 Words   |  9 Pagesinvestments while, as domestic wages and prices rise relative to those abroad, reducing the balance of trade surplus. This will then just offset the positive effects that were originally attained. 3. Explain Schumpeter’s critique of Marshall’s critique of Jevons’s critique of Ricardo. Ultimately, however, Schumpeter’s defence of marginal-utility theory proved neither relevant nor necessary. From what you have since learned about the history of economic theory, why do you think this occurred? Read MoreThe Criminal Justice System For Two Reasons784 Words   |  4 Pagesmachine and acquire some professional and legal status. Second, they commit a crime and must go to prison. The focus of the present critique is on the study that tested the validity of a prison inmate inventory and its implications for the criminal justice field. The discussed article was published by Degiorgio in the International Journal of Offender Therapy and Comparative Criminology in February 2015. The whole journal was devoted to the analysis of recidivism issues, with a particular emphasisRead MoreThe Bolshevik Revolution, By Edward Carr1578 Words   |  7 Pagesthe Bolsheviks can be explained further by Theda Skocpol. In her work States and Social Revolutions, Skocpol gives her own analysis to why revolutions occur. In this piece she explains the forces that cause states to revolt, using an inductive methodological approach focusing on three separate revolutions-- France, Russia, and China. She made an important and rather crucial distinction between â€Å"rebellion† and â€Å"revolt†. Unlike the Marxian view that â€Å"revolutions happen through class struggle, SkocpolRead MoreEssay about The Sociological Framework of Harriet Martineau1007 Words   |  5 Pagesaesthetic considerations are as key to their metho d as much as scientific observation and representation. Critics have considered both Society in America, Martineaus most widely known work which attacks the reality/rhetoric issues confronting methodological strategy and ethnocentrism, and her foundational treatise on sociological theory in data collection, How to Observe Morals and Manners. These works were born out of Martineaus two-year empirical study of the United States, which was publishedRead MoreBehaviorism And Its Impact On The Learner2285 Words   |  10 Pagesstructuralism. It is an addition of Rational Positivism. Among the major contributors and creators of behaviorism are Ivan Pavlov, John Watson, B.F. Skinner, Bandura, E. L. Thorndike and Tolman. Keywords: stimulus-response (S-R), Operant conditioning, Methodological behaviorism, behaviorism in philosophy and Classical conditioning. Behaviorism Introduction Behaviorism is the theory, which postulates that the psychology of animals or humans can be precisely studied merely by examining and analyzing quantitativelyRead MorePhilosophical Implications of Cultural Relativism4081 Words   |  17 Pagesposition The German American cultural anthropologist Franz Boas’s epistemological position in the field of Anthropology led him in the development of cultural relativism as a methodological tool. Boas has had an enduring influence on anthropology. All anthropologists today accept Boass commitment to empiricism and his methodological cultural relativism. Boas and his students like A.L.Kroeber, R. H. Lowie, E. Sapir, R. Benedict, M. Herskovits, and M. Mead and other scholars associated with the doctrineRead MoreStatistical Tests and Meta-Analysis1280 Words   |  5 Pagesstudy outcomes for similar health effects (p. 123). Likewise, York (1994) advises that meta-synthesis is research that systematically compares studies in order to interpret meaning, to clarify research foci, and to resolve existing substantive, methodological, or interpretive problems (p. xiii). In recent years, the meta-analysis approach has been used to evaluate multiple study findings as well as to evaluate how variations in exposure levels and diagnostic procedures can influence interpretations